While we’re all currently obsessed with the studly likes of Ryan Gosling and Bradley Cooper, there were celebrities who set our hearts aflutter long before The Notebook even began filming. Remember New Kids on the Block? J.T.T.? Leonardo Dicaprio? (Yes, Leo’s still around now but let’s be real: Titanic.) (Also: The fact that he’s a reoccurring mention in the slideshow above speaks for itself.) Click through for more of our editors’ childhood crushes and see if yours made the list.